FREE CONSULTATION
By Appointment Only
470-344-8550

FREE CONSULTATION
By Appointment Only
470-344-8550

X

Get In
Touch...

Newnan Office
37 Calumet Parkway, ​Building N
​Suite N-118
Newnan, Georgia 30263

Office
470-344-8550 Phone
770-847-7326 FAX

Quick Contact Form

 

How the “Sudden Emergency” Doctrine Affects Fault in Accident Cases

When determining who is responsible for causing a car accident, Georgia courts generally expect drivers to exercise ordinary care under the circumstances. However, not every emergency situation gives a driver enough time to make a judicious decision. The “sudden emergency doctrine” recognizes that when confronted with an unexpected and urgent situation, a reasonable person may make a split second decision that, with the benefit of hindsight, might not have been the best possible choice.

As established by court precedent, the sudden emergency doctrine means that a driver who must react instantly to unpredictable events and does so reasonably is not chargeable with negligence. Examples of such events are a pedestrian or animal darting unexpectedly into the roadway, a piece of debris or an obstruction suddenly appearing in a driver’s path or another driver making an abrupt maneuver. Or, a driver might experience a medical exigency such as a heart attack or seizure. The key is that the hazard appeared without warning and left the driver without time for thought to react judiciously.

However, the doctrine has significant limitations. Georgia courts have consistently held that an adverse weather condition does not qualify as a sudden emergency, because rain, fog, ice and other weather hazards are generally predictable and drivers are expected to adjust their behavior accordingly. 

Just as important, the doctrine does not protect a driver who contributed to the accident through their own negligence, such as by speeding, texting, following too closely or otherwise operating their vehicle carelessly before the emergency arose. Georgia’s modified comparative negligence calls for liability to be allocated among the parties based on their respective contribution to causing the accident. 

If you are injured in a car accident, an experienced Georgia auto accident attorney can rebut use of the sudden emergency doctrine as a defense in your case. This requires gathering evidence to show that:

  • The hazard was visible long enough for a reasonably attentive driver to recognize and avoid it.
  • The defendant was traveling too fast for the road conditions.
  • The defendant created the danger of a rear-end collision by following too closely.
  • The alleged emergency was actually a foreseeable risk, such as congested highway conditions, construction zones, school zones or inclement weather.
  • There was a lack of proper vehicle maintenance, if the defendant claims a tire blowout, brake failure or steering malfunction created the emergency.

Accident reconstruction experts can be retained to test whether the driver’s actions were consistent with an actual emergency. In addition, dashcam footage and other video evidence may be presented.

At the Law Office of S. Mark Mitchell, LLC in Newnan, Georgia, I represent victims of auto accidents in the Southwestern Atlanta Metro area. Call 470-344-8550 or contact me online to arrange a free consultation.